Where to Buy MTG Singles Online: TCGPlayer, Card Kingdom, and More
Compare the best places to buy Magic: The Gathering singles online. Pricing, shipping, condition accuracy, and which to choose.
Buying singles is the most cost-effective way to build a Commander deck. But where should you buy them? Here's an honest comparison.
TCGPlayer
Pros: Largest marketplace, usually the lowest prices, massive selection Cons: Multiple sellers means multiple shipments, condition can vary by seller Best for: Price-conscious buyers who don't mind waiting for multiple packages
Card Kingdom
Pros: Accurate condition grading, fast shipping, single shipment, great buylist Cons: Slightly higher prices than TCGPlayer market low Best for: Players who want reliability and convenience
Tapped Decks
Pros: Integrated with our deck builder (export directly to cart), condition-graded singles, proxy ordering option Cons: Smaller inventory (we sell from our collection) Best for: Building a complete deck through our platform and buying the cards in one place
eBay
Pros: Good for hard-to-find cards, auction format can score deals Cons: Risk of counterfeits, inconsistent condition grading, slow shipping Best for: Specific cards you can't find elsewhere
Local Game Stores
Pros: Support local business, no shipping, can inspect cards before buying Cons: Higher prices, limited selection Best for: Picking up a few cards you need right now
The Smart Approach
- Build your deck on Tapped Decks
- Export to TCGPlayer for the best prices on most cards
- Buy any cards we have in stock directly from our shop
- Check Card Kingdom for anything out of stock elsewhere
Our deck builder's TCGPlayer export button adds your entire 100-card deck to a TCGPlayer cart in one click.
Build Your Deck Now
Use Tapped Decks to generate a complete Commander deck in seconds. AI-powered, budget-aware, and free to try.
Start Building